Delivering the male
Published: October 12, 2011
Man Up (7:30pm Tue, ABC) I usually wince when a network sitcom panders to the 18-49 male demographic (see this year’s Last Man Standing, last year’s Traffic Lights). But the new Man Up hits this demographic where it hurts. It’s a brilliant satire of male pretension and pride, so painfully on target that it might drive away the very viewers it seeks to attract.
Man Up joins fellow one-camera, no-laugh-track productions New Girl, Up All Night, and Suburgatory at the top of this season’s sitcom class. It’s about three friends (Mather Zickel, Christopher Moynihan, Dan Fogler) obsessed with manhood, or what passes for it these days among suburban pharmaceutical reps and insurance salesmen. While their ancestors fought in World War II and Vietnam, these dudes battle each other in videogames, armed with controllers and headsets. They would never cuss around the kids, using “fluffin’” as a substitute for more salty language. And they opt for non-dairy hazelnut creamer for their coffee, since dairy, you see, is no good for the cholesterol.
All three actors find the sweet spot between reality and absurdity. Special props go to Fogler, who might be the fall season’s breakout comic star. He’s a short, bearded combination of Jack Black and Yosemite Sam, with a voice that rises into the screechy Sam Kinison register when he gets hysterical. Which is often. Man Up is a fluffin’ masterpiece.
Work of Art (8pm Wed, Bravo) When this reality series debuted last season, I denounced Bravo’s attempt to subject fine art to the genre’s kitschy formula of time-based challenges and eliminations. Now, with season two premiering, I’ve gotten over myself. I admit that Work of Art is an absorbing hour of TV and a cut above most reality offerings.
The artists make for fascinating subjects. They’re naturally obsessive, thoughtful, and eccentric, and the producers don’t have to cook up contrived interpersonal nastiness to get us interested in them. But for me, the best thing about Work of Art is the fact that a real critic is featured on the judges’ panel: the cranky, bullheaded, imperious Jerry Saltz of New York Magazine. It’s a rare treat to hear actual critical insight on reality TV, as when Saltz says of one contestant’s work, “I think you embedded thought in material.”
If Work of Art needs another cranky, bullheaded, imperious critic for season three, I think I know where to find one. (Hint, hint.)
Whitney (8:30pm Thu, NBC) One kind of network series has become so common that it might have to be declared a genre: the square sitcom that tries to fake hipness with a steady stream of sex jokes. The new Whitney is a classic example, as romantic pair Whitney (Whitney Cummings) and Alex (Chris D’Elia) slay the laugh track with smutty, witless punchlines. “Mark went home with the pregnant girl. He wanted to know if it counted as a threesome!” Maybe Whitney’s writers are so obsessed with sex because they’ve never had any. Here’s hoping they do soon so they can figure out what’s actually funny about it.